Mommy Wars, again. Or I guess more properly, Mummy Wars. (That makes me think of some sci-fi where Tut and Akhenaten battle, WWF style.)
I relate to this "women's issue" like I relate to aspartame consumption, or articles on relationships that have to start with basics like not lying, or chick flicks in which women talk and talk and talk and talk.
In other words, I don't relate.
The guilt mothers feel is so pervasive, so debilitating, you'd think it would be something they'd try to shed. But true to some inner drive gone amok, they instead bond over it, which I find inexplicable. They use it as co-miseration fodder. Like trashing their husbands. To which I also do not relate. Not that T is perfect (nor am I, for that matter--I know, shocking!), or that we don't have our less than stellar moments, but I don't tend to share them with others, or if I do it never goes beyond a few words and meaningful looks. And even that's rare. Mostly because I don't believe in leaving problems to fester, but deal with them with him within a few days whenever possible, and certainly as soon as possible in any case.
But back to guilt. Here's the ultimate thing I have to say on this subject. Attention parents (I guess especially mommies): The fact that you feel pangs of guilt means you're a conscientious parent, and therefore probably a fine parent. Which means you can rest easy. Guilt as an over-arching model is toxic and should be dealt with and let go. Either be at peace with your choices or change them, but you do not get to cry on anyone's shoulder about it more than once. It's not good for you or your children. Either vaccinate or don't, but move on once you decide, and don't feel judged by the decisions of others. Nurse or don't, for a long time, or not at all, but don't feel like you need to explain yourself. Public or private, nanny and or pre-k, homeschool or boarding school, just do what works for you and get on with it.
I find the most refreshing thing is when I meet a family that does things differently than we do and they can be friendly with us because they're secure in their decisions. We're different and it's fine with all of us.
What's frustrating is having each of my decisions feel so damn political that it's polarizing. I may not feel guilty, but may inspire guilt in another! Ack! That is not the idea at all! So because we chose to birth at home (and have been able to), choose delayed partial vaccination, nurse for three years, homeschool, co-sleep, use homeopathy and chiropractors with doctors only as needed, limit t.v., mix cloth diapers with gdiapers and huggies, limit sugar, seriously shun battery-operated toys unless there is something truly redeeming about them, never-ever-ever use artificial sweeteners, and choose movies very carefully so they are not vapid, or insulting to intelligence, or at least are well animated, never mind eating fruit and vegetables in quantity, and no video games, we are somehow pariahs among those who choose differently. They secretly suspect us of being vegetarians, or worse. But ultimately they feel perhaps judged, and quite possibly guilty. (This has been expressed on more than one occasion.) No, no, no. Not the point at all.
There is a difference between wondering or differing and having it move all the way to guilt. We had a wondering moment today about homeschooling. Not a full-on second guessing, but a discussion between T and myself and K. It was due to K having a bit of a strop about my mentioning hitting the books today. Is homeschooling still working for all of us? T, yes, me, yes, K, yes, but. He asked about what she liked, what she didn't like, how she thought school might be better or worse based on what she knows. Her answers were all basically happy and healthy, with normal dislikes (too much math), and likes (vacation in winter, during peak season). She was feeling lonely. Ahh, a primo opportunity for motherly guilt. But the situation is so temporary I can let it go. We've had a wild ride with this baby, it's been hard on everyone. Once we're back in the swing of the school year she'll be happy as a clam, just like normal, with classes during the afternoons each week and Fridays with the homeschoolers. So it's okay.
The key is not to need everyone to fulfill all one's needs. Not men, not a man, not friends, not a friend, not one's children or parents. Each person and group of people fits in a piece of the community puzzle.
It does all boil down to expectations. I think there is where modern women are missing the point. That, and that they mistake talking for communicating. And they choose an adversarial position with their mates, which makes no sense. If one can't function as a team member with one's husband what is there? It's like having sex but not being able to talk about it. Isn't that backwards? Like talking about it is somehow more intimate than actually doing it?
I think the expectation of women thinking they can discuss their own feelings in book after book, their own situation, and by extension that of the women in their cohort, if not all women in general, without discussing them in relation to men in a non-adversarial way (if a goal is to find happiness with men, vs. what? Separatism?) is folly. It is an excersize in futility. It is David becoming Goliath, because women are then committing the same acts of ignorance and insensitivity that men are historically accused of (however rightfully they may be).
It would seem a new springboard for discussing women's work, at home or out of the home, would be to approach it in context. Otherwise we risk describing part of an elephant as the whole. And that leads to rifts in communication with other women, our partners, and even ourselves.
I offer these three steps as a start to a new paradigm.
Step one: Forgiveness, of ourselves and others.
Step two: Commitment to working together, and accepting nothing less than loving communication.
Step three: Embracing our decisions, and doing what we need to do to find validation from outside sources, and further, validating the ideas of our partners, or working to find solutions so we both can stand together. Also understanding opposition is not a working relationship quality but sensational in an unhealthy way within the context of a loving relationship, and that the language we use with each other matters. Every time.
If feminism is about feeling happy and whole as women, we cannot ignore the people we choose to share our lives with, to bear our children with. The newest aspect of feminism starts at home, with our partners. When that relationship is comfortable, romantic and in tune, kids notice. Because parents are happy. Then the kids and parents will be fine with whatever the work mommy does, because there's no buyer's remorse, just commitment.